In early December, I asked a select panel of beer-geeks to come up with
their nominees for the best beers available in West Virginia — and also the worst. Since I had a discriminating panel of judges, all that was left to do was to come up with a catchy name for our annual award. I thought about how prizes like the “TONY” awards came up with their name by using an acronym based on the organization giving the awards. “Beers to You” would obviously be “BTY”…. I give you the “Booty” awards!
The “select panel” is made up of 3 people:
Charles Bockway is somewhat of a wine-geek as well as a beer-geek; always with an open mind and a closed wallet, he has a keen ability to spot beverages that deliver the greatest bang for the buck.
Chris Workman is an all-round contrarian and “wrecking ball” of any online forum or thread in which he participates. He is also a beer-geek with an insatiable desire for Uber-hoppy ales.
Then there is me. An opinionated beer-geek and “annoying patron” to most barkeeps in the local area. I am a “take no prisoners” crusader in the fight to insure each and every craft beer realize its full potential as it leaves its cozy container to appear “center stage,” after having been properly poured into a room temperature, beer-clean glass. (Is that really too much to ask?)
Winner of a 2007 “Booty” for Best Beer in the State of West Virginia: (Remember, this is still a relatively small feat to achieve with the current “restrictive beer laws”. Many of the World’s best beers are unavailable here)

Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter (Cleveland, OH) – I cannot say too many good things about this modern American classic. This is “Robust Porter”… I only wish the distributor in Charleston would sell it in kegs so we could drink it on tap! (I am told that the real reason is the distributor is incapable of properly supporting bars that would choose to sell it on tap, meaning they don’t have the knowledge or the will to properly set-up and maintain draft systems… Outrageous! Maybe they need to stick to wine…)
Winner of the 2007 “Booty” for Best New Beer in WV:
1st Place – St. Peter’s Cream Stout (Suffolk, UK) – Wow! That’s what I said the first time that I sipped one of these earlier in 2007. This beer has it all for a cream stout. It’s rich, full-bodied and is an explosion of roasted flavors with raisin, dates and hints of vanilla. Don’t tell me you don’t like dark beer until you have tried this one. I wonder how much more yummy this would be from a cask?
(more…)