On alpha cats and beta dogs
Friday, May 26th, 2006A considerate person wouldn’t tell this tale, wouldn’t air something like this in public. A considerate person wouldn’t subject their boys to the shame.
But I’m not that person.
Since my boys cannot read, and since it’s a safe bet none of their friends can read either, I feel no need to hold back. I’ll come right out and say it. In our house, the alpha dog is a cat.
I’m not sure how it happened. I always assumed there was some type of natural order, a hierarchy of beasts. Apparently, both our dogs–my boys–snoozed through that class.
Since Murry was the first animal to set paw in our house, it seemed logical to expect he would reign, but when we brought home a tiny kitten several months later, Murry immediately rolled onto his back, baring his belly. The quintessential dog sign of submission.
“Squirt’s not even as big as your paw,” I reasoned, befuddled by my dog’s rapid acquiescence. But there was no reasoning with Murry. He’d determined the kitten was king.
A year later, we added a second cat, Gypsy. Murry immediately deferred to her, too, even though for the first few months, Gypsy trembled at the sight of him in a way that would’ve made other dogs strut. Not Murry, though. Her reaction concerned him, and he apparently wanted to make her feel better–the only way he knew how. He began submitting to her with such frequency that her terror evolved into confusion, then bemusement, then scorn and disgust.
Sully (Cat No. 3) weaseled his way into our home in such a long and roundabout manner that I paid little attention to whether Murry was behaving the same way with him as the others. I do know, however, that when my humble pooch was tied in front of our house one afternoon, the big cat took sentry duty. When a roaming dog attempted to get to Murry, Sully stood on hind legs, groundhog fashion, and with much hissing and spitting, chased off the dog. So not only had Murry sublimated himself to three cats, one had become his protector.

And then came the pup, just four months old and maybe six pounds. I had no doubt our 40-pound, four-year-old Murry would flop onto his back and expose that much-viewed belly of his all over again.
He did not disappoint. Except this time, his audience missed his act of contrition. Because the pup was also on the floor on his back, baring his belly.
“You be the alpha dog.”
“No. You.”
It’s like living with the two most polite creatures ever born. If both arrive at the water bowl at the same time, each defers to the other. Neither one drinks. Set a dish of food on the floor–very same thing.
Taking the boys for a walk can be a humiliating experience, as both usually spend as much time on their backs as their feet.
I’m anticipating the day they hear a dog bark on TV and both go belly-up.
Squirt, in the meantime, seems convinced he’s done something to deserve their capitulation. He patrols his domain in a swaggering manner, stomach swaying, head held high. On whim, he butts them away from the food dish, checks their breath for contraband, nudges them from the best sunny spots on the carpet.
And the boys just take it. Like it’s the most natural thing in the world.






