The Amazing Grace of Caregivers
Although it’s been a while since Dad and I have raced, I don’t doubt that he could outrun me. I know he can out-debate me (and he’d say out-think me). My mom can out-walk, out-talk, and out-laugh me. She’s more flexible in her 70s than I was as a teen and remembers details about events that I’ve long forgotten. I’m not sure it’s a testament to how well they’re doing or how poorly I am, but I do know one thing–I’m grateful they are.
When in the waiting room at my doctor’s office recently, a woman about my age came in with her mom, who appeared to be suffering from Alzheimer’s disease. She helped her still young-looking mother settle in a chair, then went to sign in. The mother immediately began rooting through the purse, grew quickly frustrated, then dumped the purse upside-down and shook out the contents. When she still couldn’t find (or perhaps remember) what she was after, she began to cry. All in the time it took her daughter to sign her name on a page.
The daughter turned. Her shoulders immediately drooped and she closed her eyes for just a moment, then she hurried to her mother’s side. She scooped the contents back into the purse, talking in a calm, soothing voice.
The mother kept repeating, “I just wanted a tissue. I needed a tissue.” She looked deeply embarrassed, suddenly aware there were others in the room. Someone handed her a box of tissues, but the mother couldn’t seem to stop repeating that she needed a tissue.
The daughter sat and put her arm around her mother, then asked the strangest question. “Were you ever any good at throwing?” I saw the hint of a smile on her mother’s face. She sniffled, mopped at her tears with the back of her hand, much like a child, then smiled broadly.
“I’m wicked good at baseball.”
Until the nurse called my name, I listened to the mother recount her stats and those of the other women on her long-ago team with such pride. Thinking back on it later, I wished I could’ve said something to the daughter. I’m not sure what, but something to acknowledge what she was doing. I kept thinking about how hard it must be–how exhausting and emotionally draining and thankless. I could tell she was tired, but she the way she cared for her mother was something special to see.
My friend Mary Rodd Furbee, who died in 2004 at age 49, once wrote a beautiful article called “A Song for my Father.” In it, she wrote,
“Last week, I sang to my seventy-five-year-old father, who has Alzheimer’s disease. I took the hands that rarely cease their futile effort to remove the canvas restraints that tie him to his hospital bed, looked into his half-closed eyes, and sang Red River Valley. It was his favorite song.
“Slowly, he raised his head, opened his eyes, and gazed up at me like a lost child who has found his mother. When the song ended, this agitated, drugged-up, tied-down, malnourished man who rarely speaks an intelligible word begged for more. So I sang–It’s a Long Way to Tipperary, Get Me to the Church on Time, Daisy-Daisy, Rock-A-Bye Baby–eliciting the sweetest imaginable euphoria and calm.
“For an hour he gazed at me, transfixed with a joy so powerful that tears streamed down his face. Afterward, he was more relaxed than I had seen him in years.”
I admire people who handle this cruel disease with such grace. It seems the automatic response to hearing the same thing repeated dozens of times would be to yell, “You told me already!” But that accomplishes nothing but humiliating the person, making them sad.
When my friend’s mom began having trouble remembering, her husband would often pretend not to be able to remember it either. The two of them would share a laugh about how it stinks getting old. It seemed like a nice way to keep her from being depressed, and allow her to keep some dignity, too.
My friend often talked about each stage in the reversal of her mother’s abilities, until her body had even forgotten how to swallow. When she’d talk about caring for her mother, about changing her diapers or sleeping in a chair in front of her mom’s door so she couldn’t “escape,” she always sounded so removed. It wasn’t until years later that she could talk about how her mom would occasionally become briefly lucid again. She said they’d have these amazing talks, like they were catching up after a long trip, and then she’d be gone.
“Those times were both the best and the worst,” she wrote in an email. “When it was done, I’d be left feeling robbed, like I had lost her all over again. I’d have to work hard to focus on what of her was still left.”
I pray I’ll never know firsthand what it’s like to be in that place. I want to believe I’d be able to handle it with the same grace and good humor that I’ve admired in others. But I don’t want to know.

March 5th, 2007 at 6:50 am
In our culture the people who receive the greatest homage are those who stand on a stage or appear on a screen, play in a stadium or hold a high office. We call them celebrities. We pay absolutely no attention and provide no honors to those far more deserving of our accolades like the people you mentioned. There are so many others like them who quietly and without reward devote years of their lives performing acts of caring for no other reason than it is simply the right thing to do. They wield no power over the multitudes, receive no adoration from the throngs, and no gigantic paychecks. It is not power, fame, or fortune that drives them but simple selflessness the likes of which humbles me to my core. And whenever reminded, as in your commentary that such worthy souls walk among us I find myself, while thinking about them, reciting aloud the final lines of Kipling’s poem in metaphoric praise-
Though (life’s) belted you and flayed you, By the livin’ Gawd that made you, You’re a better man than I am, Gunga Din!
March 6th, 2007 at 9:14 am
That kind care and devotion may be the purest form of love one can give.
My grandmother was in the early stages of Alzheimer’s didease when she passed away after suffering a stroke. She was a very independent, vibrant, and sometimes outspoken and opinionated lady (who fried the best bacon and baked the best cherry pies that ever graced a table!), and I’m sure that, given a choice, she would have preferred physical death to the living, breathing, walking death that is Alzheimer’s disease. I thank God that she was spared that, and would not wish it on anyone.
March 10th, 2007 at 5:22 pm
Hi Karin,
I really liked your article — in fact, the first thing that came to my mind was that you are a good writer and would be an asset and might enjoy being part of a writing group. I am from S.C. and married and moved here in May. In S.C. I belonged to a women’s writers group and I loved it. It was a really nice way to be with people who are also working on a novel, short stories, a book of poetry,etc… share your thoughts and get feed back from a supportive group. I would like to form or join a writer’s group in Charleston and have put up a small poster in Taylor’s Books and in the main library. The posters were for a women’s writers group and I haven’t received any responses.
After reading your second blog, I thought that you might be interested and/or have some ideas.
March 11th, 2007 at 7:30 pm
your column made me think of my mother who has been gone for several years. I was telling my husband that it hurt so much to think about her because when I did I remembered her more as being sick than well and it hurt too much. He never really knew my mother because she was already getting sick by the time he meet her but he told me what he remembered most about her was something she did while she was sick. My brother had the meanest rooster in W.VA. That rooster chased everyone out of my mom and dads yard. My dad got many a laugh out of watching that rooster run EVERONE and I mean eveyone out of the yard. Anyway back to my mother. Everytime the rooster would chase someone out of the yard she would go out and kick that mean old rooster. The rooster never hurt my mother not once. My mother was in the final stages of alzheimers by this time. Now when I think of my mother I remember and laugh instead of cry. Thanks for bringing this memory to me again by reading your column
March 13th, 2007 at 9:15 am
Thanks for the comments! I love the rooster story.