Red Hot Chili Peppers need a kick
Monday, May 22nd, 2006
The CD: “Stadium Arcadium”
PERFORMER: Red Hot Chili Peppers
WEBSITE: Click here
“Stadium Arcadium” is a curious beast of an album. Clocking in at over two hours, you’d think that this new release from the Red Hot Chili Peppers would be an example of bloated excess. And you’d be right, sort of. It’s definitely a humongous chunk of music–too much to take in at one listen. However, except for a couple of obvious filler tunes, it’d be hard to trim this work down. There’s certainly more than a single CD worth of good music here.
Having said that, this is still a disappointing album. While there’s more than a CD’s worth of good music, there isn’t that much “great” music spread across the two CDs. For this album, the Peppers reunited with producer Rick Rubin, with whom they recorded their breakthrough album “Blood Sugar Sex Magic,” and in many ways this album seems more like an attempt to revisit past glories than a fresh artistic statement. Fans of the Chili Peppers won’t be surprised. There’s nothing really new here. You still get Anthony Kiedis’ quintessential rock star vocals, virtuoso bass and guitar work by Flea and John Frusciante, and a lyrical focus on Southern California as the center of the universe. The band is still a melting pot that can manage to borrow heavily from Lynyrd Skynyrd, hardcore punk, and classic soul, and somehow wind up sounding like themselves.
Unfortunately, that homogeneity works against them. It’s not quite “Tedium Arcadium”, but at several points while listening to this CD, I was struck by how great the band sounds, but how uninspired the material seems to be. It reminded me of the Rolling Stones in the early 1980s, when they were the most polished musically that they had ever been, but couldn’t even come close to writing songs as memorable as they had fifteen years earlier. The Chili Peppers play better than they ever have, but can’t write song like they used to. “Stadium Arcadium” features the same mix of pop ballads and alterna-funk that they’ve been cranking out for the last two decades. The high quality of the musicianship makes the blandness of the songs more glaring.
There are exceptions. “Snow (Hey Oh)” is a catchy little half-rap with a memorable guitar riff and a great chorus. “Stadium Arcadium,” the title track, is one cheesy synthesizer away from sounding like ASIA, but at least it doesn’t sound too much like their previous work. “21st Century” harkens back to their pre-success days, with a percolating new wave synth and a killer bass line.
This may sound sacrilegious, but maybe the guys should consider bringing in an outside lyricist. Musically, this is a killer album for the most part. Lyrically, it falls flat. “She’s Only 18″ is a sad lament about how tough it is when your date is more than twenty years younger than you. Boo-freakin’-hoo! What are they going to do next, write a blues song about how their limo is the wrong color? These guys seem to be at the height of their powers as musicians. It’s a shame that they also seem to be about a decade past their peak as songwriters.
— By Rudy Panucci






